American Idol Season 23 has revealed its Top 5 after two more hopefuls were eliminated Sunday night (May 11).
Season 23 of American Idol is quickly coming to a close. With only one week of competition left until a new champion is crowned, every performance is a crucial chance for the hopefuls to convince America that they deserve to win.
During Sunday’s Disney Night and Mother’s Day episode, the remaining seven contestants had the opportunity to sing twice: Once with a song dedicated to their moms and again with a cover of a Disney movie hit.
Filmed at Disneyland, the contenders were mentored by actor, playwright, and Broadway star Lin-Manuel Miranda. The Disney songs each hopeful performed were leaked ahead of the episode.
While the Disney songs brought a lighthearted feel to the episode, the song performances for the moms delivered plenty of emotion.
The songs each of the Top 7 performed in honor of their moms were:
Breanna Nix – “Like My Mother Does” by Lauren Alaina
Jamal Roberts – “A Change Is Gonna Come” by Sam Cooke.
Mattie Pruitt – “Those Kind Of Women” by Lauren Alaina
John Foster – “Believe” by Brooks & Dunn
Slater Nalley – “Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right” by Bob Dylan
Thunderstorm Artis – “Out Of The Blue” by Thunderstorm Artis
Gabby Samone – “Home” from The Wiz
As in weeks past, the voting window opened at the beginning of the show and closed during the final commercial break. Fans were given two hours to vote for who they would like to see advance to the Top 5. The two contestants who didn’t receive enough votes to advance were eliminated.
The five who survived the brutal cut will perform again Monday night, where two more will be sent home, and the Top 3 will be revealed.
American Idol Season 23 Top 5 Revealed
The five hopefuls who advance to Monday night’s semi-finals are….Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis.
The two singers who were sent home in an emotional elimination were …. Mattie Pruitt and Gabby Samone.
The judges were clearly surprised by the results and didn’t try to hide it. Viewers didn’t miss their candid reactions and took to social media.
“When the contestant you thought was gonna win gets voted off,” one X user captioned a photo of the judges.
When the contestant you thought was gonna win gets voted off #AmericanIdol #gabbysamone pic.twitter.com/rlUDBM40CN
— Bassloord (@ChrissNeedsSUBS) May 12, 2025
See the emotional and surprising elimination in the video below.